FX’s Bret Easton Ellis adaptation is immaculate and airless at first, then becomes genuinely alive the moment it stops behaving.
Los Angeles in 1981 arrives as a series of reflections. Chrome, pool water, sliding glass, the lenses of very expensive sunglasses, the polished hood of a car idling outside a house the size of a small hotel. That is the world ‘The Shards’ opens on, and I want to be fair to it immediately, because it is a genuinely seductive place to spend an evening.
Ryan Murphy and Bret Easton Ellis have circled the same obsessions for decades, the beautiful surface and the rot beneath it, and when their sensibilities finally meet in this adaptation of Ellis’s autobiographical novel, the result is lush, decadent, frequently ridiculous, and never once boring to look at. It is built for the particular pleasure of watching gorgeous, doomed young people move through rooms that cost more than most people make in a decade, and it makes no apology for that.
The pairing has the ring of inevitability. Ellis has spent a career anatomizing the spiritual vacancy of the American rich, from the sun-bleached anomie of ‘Less Than Zero’ to the designer savagery of ‘American Psycho‘, always writing bodies and brands with the same flat, clinical attention until the accumulation itself becomes the horror.
Murphy, across ‘American Horror Story’, ‘Feud’, and his true-crime work, has built an empire on the opposite instinct, on excess, camp, and the operatic reveal, on turning private ugliness into public spectacle. One writer withholds. The other detonates. ‘The Shards‘ is the sound of those two temperaments negotiating a truce that neither fully honors, and the friction is, at its best, the most interesting thing on screen.
The setup is pure teenage noir. Bret, played with careful blankness by Igby Rigney, is starting his senior year at an elite prep school, drifting through a circle of the impossibly privileged whose parents are absent, distracted, or too busy feeding their own appetites to notice anything. There is his girlfriend Debbie, his imperious best friend Susan, her boyfriend Thom, and the entire pharmacy of drugs, sex, and boredom that unsupervised money can buy.
Bret belongs to this world completely and hides almost everything about himself inside it, and his narration studies each scene from behind glass, as if he is already writing the novel we are watching.
Two disruptions break the circuit. The first is Robert Mallory, a startlingly beautiful transfer student with a psychiatric stay in his past. The second is the Trawler, a killer stalking rich kids across the city whose crimes keep drifting toward Bret’s friends. Bret becomes convinced the two are connected, and the show is smart enough never to confirm whether that is detective instinct or jealous fantasy.
That uncertainty is the series at its most cunning. Bret is a novelist in formation, and the show understands that his greatest talent and his greatest danger are the same thing, an ability to arrange other people into a story with himself at the center.
He wants Robert, fears him, and resents the pull Robert exerts on everyone around him, and the show keeps asking whether he has identified a monster or built one to contain everything he cannot admit he wants. When it trusts that ambiguity, it generates a genuine unease that has nothing to do with the killer and everything to do with the narrator. When it does not, it reaches for the soundtrack.
The seduction comes with a real cost, and it shows up early. In its opening episodes, ‘The Shards’ is exquisite and airless. It wants to be an icy thriller and it dresses the part flawlessly, but ice needs a temperature to register, and I was rarely cold. The Trawler’s killings, grotesque on paper, arrive with the same lacquered calm as the parties, arranged rather than felt.
The soundtrack is impeccable and relentless, whole sequences surrendered to a single song until a drive to nowhere becomes a music video, and I began to suspect the show cared more about preserving the needle drop than the people inside the frame. Everything is correct. That was my note, scene after scene. Everything is correct, and for a while almost nothing is alive. There is enough atmosphere here to satisfy on mood alone, but I kept waiting for the thriller to tighten around my throat, and early on it rarely does.
Part of the trouble is that Ellis on the page runs on an interior rhythm television cannot fake. His obsessive cataloging of streets, labels, records, and bodies works as prose precisely because the repetition becomes oppressive, a numbing inventory that tells you exactly how empty this world is.
On screen, that same impulse curdles into decoration. The production design is genuinely spectacular, the costumes fitted with almost architectural precision, the cars and sunglasses and record collections deployed like extensions of personality, the period pop culture laid on thick enough to taste. It is beautiful, and it is also a kind of wall.
These children have been raised to present as finished products before they had selves to finish, and the airlessness is arguably the point, a formal echo of their curated emptiness. Arguably. But an argument for coldness is not the same as making coldness dramatic, and for a stretch I was admiring the thesis rather than living inside the show.
Then, later in the series, the show does something I would not dream of spoiling for an audience only two installments in. I will say only this. The restraint does not hold. Having watched further, I can promise the series does not stay this composed, and the moment it breaks is the moment it becomes genuinely itself.
From there it loosens its grip on Ellis and gives itself over to Murphy’s appetite for horror-comedy, growing messier, funnier, and far more willing to embarrass itself. The result is not well-behaved television. It does real damage to the season’s coherence. It is also the exact point where I started having fun, and for anyone who has ever loved Murphy at his most volatile, it is where the show finally becomes the party the opening kept promising. He has always been more compelling when he risks embarrassment than when he settles for good taste, and here, eventually, he risks plenty.
The cast is worth the price of admission on its own. Rigney plays Bret’s flatness as armor rather than emptiness, and is at his best when the mask slips, when want and fear and envy crowd into a single look he cannot quite control. Homer Gere is shrewdly used as Robert precisely because the character is a blank everyone paints their fears onto, though the role occasionally reads as a bundle of warning signs rather than a person.
Kaia Gerber gives Susan a brittle, rule-bound poise, the composure of a girl who has memorized the social code and cannot afford to look uncertain. But the one who genuinely surprised me is Hayes Warner as Debbie, who begins as another confident rich girl and slowly reveals the humiliation and fury underneath, so that her cruelty stops being camp and becomes the most human thing in the show.
Among the adults, Wes Bentley wears menace as calm, Evan Rachel Wood moves between real anguish and high melodrama without dropping either, and Jordan Roth, as the family assistant, is so theatrically self-aware that he seems to have read the script and to be nudging everyone toward disaster. He is barely in the same show as the teenagers, and after a while that becomes part of the pleasure.
The cost of all this style is real, and worth naming. The most affecting thread in Ellis’s novel is Bret’s private, unspoken tenderness for another young man, the loneliness beneath the whole performance, and so far the adaptation gives it too little room. Without it, Bret is hard to reach past his fixation on Robert and the murders, and I found myself admiring these people as mannequins long before the show gave me a reason to fear for them. A thriller has to make loss feel possible. This one keeps everyone at a beautiful distance and seems, at least early, mildly surprised the distance holds.
The tension between surface and humanity runs through nearly every frame, in costumes that overwhelm the actors wearing them, in songs more carefully protected than the relationships they score, in murders staged with more conviction than the victims are ever granted.
What I am left with is a show at war with itself, and honest enough not to hide it. ‘The Shards’ is not yet consistently frightening, not yet emotionally persuasive, and nobody’s idea of disciplined storytelling. What it is, based on everything I have seen, is fascinating, ridiculous, sumptuous, and a great deal more fun than its glacial opening promises once it decides to let go.
Murphy and Ellis never fully fuse. They play like two authors passing the same story back and forth, one supplying the dread, the other the color and the camp, and the seams never vanish. I stopped wanting them to.
The fracture turned out to be more interesting than the fusion would have been. It is worth showing up for the surfaces and the cast, and worth staying for the moment it all cracks open, because this is a series far more interested in momentum than resolution. I wanted more by the end, and I could not always tell whether that was the show working on me or simply Murphy doing what Murphy does.
‘The Shards’ spends its opening hours polishing every surface until nothing human breaks through, and it becomes worth watching only once it starts smashing the glass. That smashing is quite a thing to see.
THAT’S A WRAP | THE SHARDS
A glossy, feverish descent into privilege, repression, and 1981 Los Angeles that keeps everything under museum glass at first, then finally gets dangerous the second it lets the case shatter.
Jonathan P. Moustakas
CREDITS
Release Date: August 5, 2026
Created By: Ryan Murphy and Bret Easton Ellis
Cast: Igby Rigney, Kaia Gerber, Homer Gere, Hayes Warner, Graham Campbell, Wes Bentley, Evan Rachel Wood, Jordan Roth
Based On: The novel by Bret Easton Ellis
Streaming: FX and Hulu
Rated: TV-MA
Watch The Trailer Below:
Share this:
