Have a Story? A scoop, a lead, or something we should know first — reach out in confidence.

Get In Touch →

, , , , , , , ,

’12 12 12′ Review: Mackie and Dornan Lose Control of a Heist

By

·

Anthony Mackie As Fbi Agent Jack Strickland in Apple Tv's 12 12 12, reviewed
apple Tv

Apple TV’s triple-timeline thriller opens with polish, then collapses into contrivance, wasting a strong cast.

Every heist story is secretly a story about control. The mastermind sees every move in advance, the plan unfolds like clockwork, and the pleasure for the audience comes from watching a complicated machine run perfectly, or break down in exactly the right way. 12 12 12, Apple TV’s new eight-episode thriller starring Anthony Mackie and Jamie Dornan, understands that pleasure in theory. In practice, it loses control of its own machine long before the vault door swings shut.

The title comes from a piece of supposed FBI wisdom that Mackie’s agent, Jack Strickland, recites at the top of every episode: a professional robbery takes 12 months to plan and 12 hours to carry out, and a thief who is not caught within 12 days will never be caught at all. Creators Jim Keeble and Dudi Appleton turn that idea into the show’s structure, braiding together three timelines. One follows the 12-hour heist itself, as master thief Paul Galvin (Dornan) leads a crew into a heavily guarded Zurich bank to steal roughly a billion dollars belonging to Russian oligarchs. One follows the 12 months of planning that pulled Paul out of a comfortable retirement. And one follows the 12-day manhunt, as Strickland, obsessed with avenging a partner he believes Paul killed, teams with Swiss detective Lena (Sallie Harmsen) to catch him.

Jamie Dornan As Master Thief Paul Galvin in 12 12 12 on Apple Tv
apple Tv

On paper, it is a smart hook. The triple timeline promises to let us watch the plan, the execution and the investigation collide, revealing each twist from three angles at once. And for a while, it works. The first two episodes, directed by Kari Skogland, are slick and confident. The series opens with a terrific image, a contortionist unfolding himself from a safe-deposit box inside a sealed vault, and moves briskly through a nicely edited chase sequence and a clean introduction of the crew. None of it is original, and the specter of Ocean’s Eleven hangs over nearly every scene, but it is polished, efficient and fun.

The trouble starts in the middle. By the fourth episode, the show’s commitment to logic begins to crumble. A crew member survives an avalanche big enough to bury a cabin and is fine a scene later, and the avalanche turns out to be part of a getaway plan that the planning timeline never bothers to set up. It is a small moment, but a revealing one. The entire appeal of the three-timeline structure is that each strand should inform and enrich the others. When the planning episodes stop explaining the heist and the heist stops paying off the planning, the structure becomes a gimmick rather than a design.

From there, the series drifts. The middle episodes meander, circling the same character beats without deepening them, and the final two episodes abandon the careful construction altogether in favor of a string of increasingly implausible twists. A late-night chase sequence that includes an encounter with an animal is meant to be thrilling and lands as unintentionally comic. By the time the finale arrives, the show seems far more interested in surprising us than in making sense, and the final reveals feel less like a lock clicking into place than a writer reaching for one more rabbit to pull out of the hat.

Anthony Mackie As Fbi Agent Jack Strickland in Apple Tv's 12 12 12, reviewed
apple Tv+

A heist story can survive a lot of contrivance if the people at its center are compelling, but this is where 12 12 12 stumbles hardest. The cat-and-mouse dynamic between Strickland and Paul should be the engine of the series, the kind of obsessive rivalry that powered Heat or Catch Me If You Can. Instead, neither man ever becomes vivid enough to sustain eight hours.

Mackie is a reliable, charismatic actor, and he brings a steady, low-key intensity to Strickland. But the role calls for something more consuming, a man so fixated on his prey that he is willing to wreck his career and his life to catch him, and Mackie never quite finds that obsessive register. The script gives Strickland a few lines about how his race has shaped his drive to prove himself, but they feel bolted on rather than woven into the character, and they never pay off dramatically.

Dornan has the opposite problem. He has been at his best playing either chilling darkness, as the serial killer in The Fall, or gleeful silliness, as in Barb and Star Go to Vista Del Mar. Paul gives him neither. He is a mastermind defined almost entirely by competence, calm and cool where he should be dangerous and magnetic. Without a hint of menace or wit, the show’s central rival feels hollow, and it is hard to care whether he gets away with it.

The supporting cast is full of talented actors given too little to do. Kali Reis, so memorable in True Detective: Night Country, is largely sidelined as a member of the crew. Agathe Rousselle, the star of the Palme d’Or winner Titane, plays Paul’s pregnant partner, Severine, but the role is more motivation than character. Harmsen’s Lena starts as a promising foil for Strickland, a sharp local detective who sees through his obsession, then disappears for long stretches of the season. Jack Kesy plays Paul’s volatile brother, Bobby, as an obvious red herring whose unpredictability never becomes genuinely threatening. Patrick Fabian makes the most of a couple of scenes as Strickland’s exasperated FBI superior, and Olafur Darri Olafsson, always a welcome presence, appears as a crew member whose actual job in the heist is never quite clear.

Review: Apple Tv's '12 12 12' Can't Pull Off the Heist
apple Tv

That last point speaks to a broader problem. The best heist stories make sure we understand every member of the team and every step of the plan, so that the moment it goes wrong becomes thrilling. 12 12 12 has a sprawling crew, including a tunneler, a contortionist, an inside woman and several others, but many of them barely register, and the plan itself grows murkier as the series goes on. For a show built around the idea of a perfectly engineered robbery, it is surprisingly fuzzy on the details.

It is also worth noting how crowded this genre has become. Television has spent years trying to reinvent the heist, from Netflix’s Kaleidoscope, which let viewers watch its episodes in any order, to Money Heist, which turned the form into a global phenomenon. The prestige dramas that work best tend to borrow the heist’s structure without being heists at all. By comparison, 12 12 12 feels like a clever format in search of a story worth telling.

The decline is especially puzzling because Skogland, who directed both the opening and closing episodes, is one of streaming’s most dependable hands, with credits ranging from The Handmaid’s Tale to The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, the Marvel series that also starred Mackie. Her first two episodes have rhythm and clarity, establishing geography, stakes and personalities with economy. Her last two feel like they belong to a different show entirely, rushed and overloaded, as if the production ran out of time to make the ending land. Whatever happened between those bookends, the result is a season that loses its shape exactly when it needs to tighten.

The setting is also underused. Zurich, with its discreet private banks, old money and reputation for secrecy, is a perfect backdrop for a story about stealing dirty oligarch cash, and the premise practically begs for a sharper look at who keeps fortunes like that and why. 12 12 12 gestures at that idea but never explores it, treating the billion dollars as a MacGuffin rather than a statement. A bolder version of the show might have found something to say about money and power in the process of stealing it.

There are pleasures here for genre fans. The production values are strong, the European locations look sleek, and the early episodes have the clean, professional sheen of a big-budget thriller. Viewers who simply enjoy watching a team of experts break into a vault may find enough to keep them going through the first act. But the show never builds on its promising start, and its biggest swings land with a thud.

12 12 12 is not a disaster. It is something more frustrating: a series with a genuinely interesting structure, two capable stars and a solid opening that gradually loses its nerve, its logic and its momentum. Twelve months in planning, perhaps. But it falls apart well before the twelfth hour.

RATING: ★★☆☆☆


That’s A Wrap | 12 12 12

A promising, triple-timeline heist thriller that opens with polish and confidence before collapsing into contrivance, wasting a strong cast on characters who never come alive.

Jonathan P. Moustakas

Watch the Trailer Below


CREDITS

Creators: Jim Keeble and Dudi Appleton
Cast: Anthony Mackie, Jamie Dornan, Kali Reis, Agathe Rousselle, Sallie Harmsen
Network: Apple TV
Episodes: 8
Premiere Date: November 13, 2026, on Apple TV

author avatar
Jonathan P. Moustakas
Jonathan P. Moustakas founded The Cinema Group in 2020 during the challenges of the pandemic, after losing the vital ability to find community in theaters and escape through the captivating magic of cinema. Feeling profoundly cut off from the vibrant film community he cherished, he sought to create a welcoming home for dedicated cinema fans while providing engaging, daily curated content that resonates with their passions. Years later, The Cinema Group has blossomed from a small collective of loyal fans into a thriving brand that reaches millions of audiences every month across a diverse array of platforms and mediums.

FOLLOW FOR MORE