A Powerful Voice for Justice: ‘Her Fight, His Name: The Story of Gwen Carr and Eric Garner’
Gwen Carr, mother of Eric Garner, center, speaks for families of New Yorkers killed by NYPD demonstrating in front of Gov. Cuomo’s 3rd Ave, Manhattan Office on July 7, 2015. (Andrew Savulich / New York Daily News)
A Story of Grief, Resilience, and Advocacy
Brad Bailey’s Her Fight, His Name: The Story of Gwen Carr and Eric Garner is a profound documentary short that marks the 10-year anniversary of Eric Garner’s tragic death. It captures the heartbreak, resilience, and activism of his mother, Gwen Carr, as she transforms unimaginable grief into a powerful force for justice. This Oscar-qualified contender for Best Documentary Short Film serves as both a memorial to Eric Garner and a rallying cry for systemic change.
On July 17, 2014, Eric Garner’s death became a flashpoint in the global fight against police brutality. Captured on video, Garner’s final words, "I can’t breathe," repeated 11 times, echoed across the world, igniting outrage and sparking widespread protests. This film doesn’t merely retell these events; it brings viewers into the deeply personal aftermath, showing the human cost of systemic failures.
The film’s core is Gwen Carr’s remarkable journey. After her son’s death, Carr transitioned from a grieving mother to a relentless advocate for justice, championing causes that extend far beyond her personal loss. Her role as a leader within the "Mothers of the Movement" highlights her ability to unite those affected by police violence, offering hope and solidarity in the face of profound injustice.
A Cinematic Journey into Advocacy
TheWrap’s Executive Editor of Awards (L-R) Steve Pond with “A Place to Fall Down” director Duane Hansen Fernandez, “Her Fight, His Name: The Story of Gwen Carr and Eric Garner” director Brad Bailey and “Once Upon a Time in Ukraine” director Betsy West at the shorts showcase on Dec. 6. (TheWrap)
Bailey’s documentary does more than document events; it provides a comprehensive exploration of the structural issues that perpetuate police violence. From the failed attempts to hold the officers accountable to the broader societal implications of institutionalized racism, the film situates Carr’s story within a larger narrative. It is a sobering reminder of the systemic barriers that hinder progress and a testament to the power of grassroots movements to challenge entrenched systems.
The visual storytelling is equally impactful. Bailey’s direction ensures the narrative stays focused on Carr’s perspective, while the evocative score by Jongnic Bontemps heightens the emotional resonance. The cinematography moves fluidly between intimate moments of reflection and scenes of large-scale activism, encapsulating both the personal and collective dimensions of the fight for justice.
Carr’s voice remains the guiding force throughout the documentary, her words imbued with a quiet yet unyielding strength. Her reflections on her son’s life and legacy bring a deeply human element to the broader fight against systemic injustice.
The Review: A Documentary of Rare Depth
FilmNorth. All Rights Reserved.
Her Fight, His Name is an extraordinary achievement in documentary filmmaking, offering a deeply personal yet universally resonant exploration of grief, resilience, and activism. Brad Bailey’s direction and Gwen Carr’s powerful story transform the film into a profound reflection on justice, systemic inequality, and the enduring strength of a mother’s love. It is rare for a documentary to so seamlessly intertwine the personal with the political, yet Bailey accomplishes this with remarkable finesse, making Her Fight, His Name both an emotional journey and a clarion call for change.
At its core, Gwen Carr’s journey forms the beating heart of the narrative. Her transformation from a grieving mother into a fierce advocate for justice is nothing short of inspiring. The documentary illustrates her journey with remarkable sensitivity, capturing the devastation of her personal loss while also showcasing her determination to turn that pain into a force for meaningful change. This duality—of anguish and activism—serves as the foundation of the film’s emotional and intellectual depth.
One of the most compelling aspects of Her Fight, His Name is its ability to connect Carr’s deeply personal experience to a broader movement. The death of her son, Eric Garner, is not just presented as an isolated tragedy but as a microcosm of the systemic failures that perpetuate police brutality and institutionalized racism. This connection illustrates how one mother’s loss reverberates across a nation, sparking protests, inspiring legislation, and galvanizing activists worldwide. The ripple effects of Garner’s death are explored in a way that is both heartbreaking and illuminating, giving audiences a profound understanding of the stakes involved in this ongoing fight for justice.
The documentary’s pacing is deliberate and thoughtful, allowing viewers to absorb the full weight of Carr’s story. Bailey resists the temptation to sensationalize her pain, opting instead for a quiet, reflective approach that emphasizes Carr’s resilience and strength. This restraint lends the film a sense of authenticity, making it resonate deeply with audiences. Each scene feels purposeful, contributing to a narrative that is as cohesive as it is impactful.
Bailey’s artistic choices extend to the documentary’s cinematography, which is both evocative and poignant. The film seamlessly transitions between archival footage, present-day interviews, and moments of peaceful reflection, creating a visual language that mirrors the emotional complexity of its subject matter. Archival footage of protests and media coverage of Garner’s death is juxtaposed with intimate moments of Carr speaking candidly about her grief and determination. This interplay between the public and the personal underscores the documentary’s central theme: that systemic change is deeply intertwined with individual stories of courage and resilience.
Another standout feature of the film is its inclusion of voices beyond Carr’s, particularly those of the “Mothers of the Movement,” a group of women who have also lost children to police violence. These voices add a layer of solidarity and interconnectedness to the narrative, showing that while Carr’s story is unique, it is also emblematic of a larger, collective struggle. The scenes featuring these mothers are some of the film’s most powerful, illustrating how shared pain can become a catalyst for collective action.
The emotional resonance of Her Fight, His Name is further heightened by its hauntingly beautiful score, composed by Jongnic Bontemps. The music strikes a delicate balance between sorrow and hope, amplifying the emotional weight of the story without overshadowing it. Bontemps’ melodies mirror the film’s tone, underscoring moments of grief while also providing a sense of uplift and determination. The score becomes an integral part of the storytelling, enhancing the film’s ability to move and inspire its audience.
While the film focuses on the pain and injustices faced by Carr and others, it also leaves room for hope. Bailey masterfully conveys the idea that change, while slow and arduous, is possible through persistence and collective effort. Carr’s resilience becomes emblematic of a universal struggle for dignity, equality, and the unyielding pursuit of truth. This balance between heartbreak and hope is what makes Her Fight, His Name such a powerful and impactful documentary.
The film also deserves praise for its nuanced approach to exploring the systemic barriers that hinder progress. Through interviews and expert commentary, the documentary delves into the challenges of holding law enforcement accountable and the societal structures that perpetuate racial inequality. This broader context enriches the narrative, providing audiences with a deeper understanding of the complexities involved in the fight for justice.
What sets Her Fight, His Name apart from other documentaries on similar topics is its unwavering focus on Gwen Carr’s voice and perspective. Bailey ensures that Carr remains the central figure throughout the film, allowing her to reclaim her narrative and tell her son’s story on her own terms. This choice is both empowering and essential, as it underscores the importance of amplifying the voices of those most directly affected by injustice.
As the documentary unfolds, it becomes clear that Her Fight, His Name is not just a film about Eric Garner’s death—it is a film about the enduring power of love, the strength of community, and the necessity of fighting for a better future. It challenges viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about systemic inequality while also inspiring them to believe in the possibility of change.
Rating: ☆☆☆☆½
Her Fight, His Name: The Story of Gwen Carr and Eric Garner is a deeply moving and impactful documentary that honors the life and legacy of Eric Garner while shining a light on the resilience and activism of his mother, Gwen Carr. It is a vital film for anyone seeking to understand the human cost of systemic injustice and the power of grassroots advocacy.
Brad Bailey’s masterful storytelling and Gwen Carr’s unyielding strength make this documentary an essential watch and a deserving contender for Oscar recognition.
Academy Voting members can WATCH the film NOW In the Academy Screening Room
Her Fight, His Name: The Story of Gwen Carr and Eric Garner is for your consideration for the 97th Academy Awards. Voting begins December 17th.
For technical support, please contact the Academy's support office at 855-742-9140 or support@oscars.org
THE CINEMA GROUP - YOUR PREMIER SOURCE FOR THE LATEST IN FILM AND ENTERTAINMENT NEWS. FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA @THECINEMAGROUP
